How to Season a Carbon Steel Frying Pan for Non-Stick Cooking

A carbon steel frying pan is one of the most versatile tools in any kitchen. However, to unlock its full potential, proper seasoning is essential. 

When seasoned correctly, a carbon steel pan develops a natural non-stick surface that improves over time, allowing for effortless cooking and easy cleanup. The right seasoning approach also ensures durability and optimal cooking performance.

Why Seasoning Is Essential for Carbon Steel Pans

Unlike stainless steel or non-stick-coated pans, carbon steel requires seasoning to create a protective layer that prevents rust and enhances its non-stick properties. This process generally involves bonding oil to the carbon steel made frying pan’s surface through polymerization, forming a hardened layer that improves with continued use.

The top benefits of seasoning a pan include:

1. Non-stick performance that allows food to slide off easily
2. Protection against rust. Without seasoning, the pan can quickly develop rust as it’s exposed to moisture in the air
3. Enhanced flavor development as the seasoning layer contributes to rich, complex tastes over time
4. Extended lifespan, ensuring your pan lasts for generations with proper care.

A step-by-step guide to seasoning

Step 1: Preparing Your Carbon Steel Pan for Seasoning

Before seasoning, your pan must be completely clean and free from any manufacturing residue, protective coatings, or rust. This ensures proper seasoning. 

What You’ll Need:

1. Hot water
2. Mild dish soap (only for initial cleaning)
3. A stiff brush or sponge
4. Paper towels or a piece of lint-free cloth

Cleaning Process:

1. Wash the pan thoroughly with hot water, a small amount of dish soap. Scrub gently with the brush or sponge to remove any factory-applied wax or protective coating.
2. Rinse well to ensure all soap is removed, as leftover residue can interfere with seasoning.
3. Dry the pan immediately after rinsing it, using paper towels or a clean cloth. Carbon steel rusts quickly, so avoid air drying.
4. Heat the pan over low heat for one to two minutes to evaporate any remaining moisture.

Step 2: Selecting the Right Oil for Seasoning

When it comes to seasoning a carbon steel frying pan, the best suited oils for seasoning it are those with a high smoke point and low saturated fat content. These oils allow for effective polymerization.

Recommended Oils:

1. Flaxseed oil—creates a durable, long-lasting seasoning layer
2. Grapeseed oil—a neutral oil that bonds well to carbon steel
3. Canola oil—an affordable and widely available option
4. Avocado oil—which has a high smoke point and works well for seasoning

Avoid butter, coconut oil, or any oil with a low smoke point, as these can break down prematurely. This results in improper seasoning of carbon steel made frying pan, promoting rusting. 

Step 3: Applying the Oil to the Pan

Coating the Surface:

1. Pour a small amount (about half a teaspoon) of oil into the pan.
2. Spread the oil evenly using a paper towel, covering the entire surface, including the bottom and exterior sides.
3. Remove excess oil, ensuring the pan appears dry and polished rather than greasy. A thin, even layer ensures proper polymerization.

Step 4: Heating the Pan for Seasoning

Heating is required in order to bake the oil onto the pan’s surface, creating the first layer of seasoning.

Using an Oven (Recommended Method)

1. Preheat the oven to 450-500°F.
2. Place the pan upside down on the oven rack to prevent pooling. Place aluminum foil on the lower rack to catch any drips.
3. Bake for about an hour to allow the oil to bond to the metal and form a protective layer.
4. Turn off the oven and let the pan cool completely inside before removing it.

Using a Stovetop 

1. Heat the pan over medium-high heat until it starts smoking.
2. Allow the oil to burn off, turning the pan occasionally to ensure even coating.
3. Let the pan cool before handling.

For best results, repeat this process three to five times, building multiple thin layers of seasoning.

Step 5: Maintaining Your Seasoned Carbon Steel Pan

While a properly seasoned carbon steel frying pan improves over time, maintenance is key to keeping it in top condition.

Cleaning Your Pan:

1. Avoid soap. After cooking, simply wipe out the pan with a paper towel or rinse with hot water.
2. Use a scrubber if necessary. For stuck-on food, use a wooden spatula or a gentle scrub brush.
3. Dry immediately. Remember to never leave your pan wet, as water can cause rust to form very quickly.

Reinforcing the Seasoning:

1. Apply a thin oil layer after each use to consistently prevent rust and keep the seasoning strong.
2. Re-season as needed, especially when food starts sticking or rust appears.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Using Too Much Oil

A thick layer results in a sticky, uneven surface rather than a smooth, non-stick coating. Therefore, always wipe away excess oil before heating.

Skipping the Initial Cleaning

Factory coatings or contaminants can interfere with seasoning, leading to an uneven finish. Always scrub the pan thoroughly before the first seasoning takes place to remove the factory coating.

Not Heating the Pan Long Enough

If the oil does not fully polymerize, the seasoning can flake off. Always allow the pan to reach high enough temperatures to bond the oil effectively.

Letting the Pan Sit Wet

Water exposure leads to rust, which weakens seasoning and shortens the pan’s lifespan. Always dry and oil your pan after each wash.

Final Thoughts

Seasoning a carbon steel frying pan is a straightforward yet crucial process that transforms the pan into a non-stick powerhouse. 

By following the correct steps for seasoning, maintaining thin layers for seasoning, and avoiding common mistakes, you can make the most of your carbon steel frying pan. Enjoy your naturally non-stick, rust-free, and long-lasting pan for years to come!

Located in PEI, Canada, The Cook’s Edge is one of the top stores that offers a wide range of Japanese knives, Chinese cleaver knives, and western knives, from affordable to rare finds. 

Choose from a variety of all types of whetstones for all general knife sharpening needs. Select the best frying pan for your needs. Invest in only genuine quality kitchen tools by visiting their physical store or shopping from their online store.